COVID-19 Update: Read our messages to employees and clients

December 22, 2015
Revenue Cycle 4: Winning Appeals

We now know that, in the first four weeks of ICD-10, 10.1% of claims filed under ICD-10 were denied, according to the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS). Although it’s only slightly higher than the historic normal denial rate of 10%, the flexibility in coding specificity that is being extended to hospitals and facilities has probably kept the denial rate artificially low.

As specificity requirements increase to the levels prescribed by the ICD-10 coding vocabulary, denials may begin to pile up. To make the transition a success, it’s going to be important to quickly and effectively have denials adjudicated and paid. Here’s what you need to know.

Bulking up the coding and billing department

According to a recent survey, 75% of hospitals and facilities anticipated a 30% drop-off in coder productivity due to ICD-10, but only 34% planned to make up for the loss by either hiring new coders or expanding relationships with external providers. Furthermore, just 28% said they planned to use both approaches to ensure coder productivity remained steady.

This could be financially fatal, especially when you consider that two-thirds of survey respondents reported having 10 or fewer coder personnel. In these situations, the loss of a single coder due to normal turnover of staff, coupled with decreased productivity for the rest of the team, could put incoming revenues on the brink. Even where coding staffs number 11–30 individuals (22%) or 30 or more (13%), expected lost productivity could equate to up to 9 or more lost personnel.

If you can’t add staff in the back office, perhaps it’s time to think about the exam room. Real-time coding, performed at the point of service by providers fully trained in and expert with ICD-10, can help ensure the right level of detail is recorded, to guide your back-office coding and billing staff in creating valid codes and submitting clean claims in the first place.

Making documentation do more

Your electronic health record (EHR) system should be chock-full of the documentation needed for coding claims and winning appeals. According to the survey, 70% of respondents are formally attempting clinical documentation improvement programs, and yet 70% are not using the technology itself to achieve these improvements.

To meet the specificity and burden of proof required by the ICD-10 code set, detailed documentation is a must. Each patient record must contain all the information needed to verify the case history, need of service documentation, procedure documentation and patient medication history. Your best answer to any denial is to provide clear, concise and thorough documentation. Using medical scribes to record the patient encounter as it happens frees up the physician to elicit the required of level of detail, while simultaneously ensuring that those details are recorded for coding evidence. Remember: If something wasn’t recorded, it wasn’t done.

Appealing a denial

First, figure out the reason or reasons the claim was denied — lack of specificity or an incorrect modifier, for example. When going back through the documentation to make the correction on the amended claim, try to spot where or how the error occurred. The patient’s name may have been misspelled, the right-side modifier may have been used instead of bilateral, the wrong insurance carrier may have been billed — there are any number of reasons, and knowing the source of the errors lets you put safeguards into place.

Payer requirements will vary, so it may be helpful to create a cheatsheet that lists denial documentation for each payer, and distribute it to all coding and billing staff. Once you’ve amended the claim and compiled the supporting documentation that will be required to overturn the denial, resubmit as soon as possible. Document the submission, including the electronic claim receipt in the patient’s file.

You may run into more problems if the reason for denial was that the initial filing was not timely — it was delayed for one reason or another, and submitted outside the payer’s required time frame after provision of service. Here is where maintaining personal relationships with your payer representatives is absolutely critical: It’s time to get on the phone. Document the reason the claim was not timely and submit the explanation, but speak to the rep, and see if he or she can help. This approach might work, it might not — but it’s your best shot. If you don’t win, it’s one to chalk up to experience.

Care Navigators
As healthcare business models evolve, so should care teams.

Patients who are paired with Care Navigators report feeling less anxiety, and an increased ability to self-manage their conditions between visits. And providers report increased job satisfaction from improved efficiency, and knowing their patients have access to care teams, and strategic support.

Chronic Care Management
With an increased aging population managing two or more chronic illnesses, extending your care teams’ ability to communicate with patients is critical. We take a strategic approach to helping patients chart a path towards their health goals, while self-managing their chronic conditions between clinical visits.

Artificial Intelligence
Our advanced AI solutions tackle complex documentation challenges to reduce the administrative burden preventing doctors from delivering precision care. We'll guide you through the best practices for incorporating AI into your workflow. Gain visibility into your data with enhanced analytics driven by AI and CTAs.

Nurse Care Team Assistants
Adding a qualified Nurse CTA to the care team increases quality of work-life and reduces stress on nurses. The nursing profession is also experiencing an alarming shortage due to increased clerical burdens and burnout.

Scribe Services
There’s a reason why we’re the nation’s most frequently used scribe company: we offer professionally trained in-person and virtual medical scribes to meet the specific needs of our clients. We offer a variety of scribe programs, as well as technology and personnel solutions that address revenue cycle management, the transition to value-based care, and more through our HealthChannels family of companies.